II.x. I Cross the Apennines
Ungrateful Florence! Dante sleeps afar, Like Scipio, buried by the upbraiding shore
- Lord Byron I am not going to attempt to explain or catalogue what there is in Florence. I am not going to go into detail about the thousands of masterpieces each worth a thousand pages of deliberation, nor am I going to talk about how Florence is the heart and soul of Western Civilisation, how for two hundred bright years it was the centre of the world.
When I visit a new or unfamiliar art museum I always do a first quick overview, walking somewhat briskly through the rooms, getting my bearings and estimating exactly how much there is to see, how much time I will need, before returning to the start and beginning to examine things in earnest.
Such was my trip to Florence on Thursday, my first visit to the city in over six years. In those six years the city has stayed the same but I have changed somewhat. Somewhat, but not entirely, for I still have that thirst for Giottos, that certain distaste for the High Renaissance, that only slightly tempered disregard for Michelangelo.
And so, barely an hour south of Bologna, I was in Florence Thursday morning chiefly to reacquaint myself with the place, more than to see anything specific. There were a few things, however, things that I had studied to my whit's end in the intervening years without actually having ever seen. This is a dangerous tendancy for art historians (or prospective ones), and so many have written with feigned authority about monuments they have never been able to see for themselves. I needed to see four things.
The first, in many ways, was the most evocative. In the church of Santa Trinità, often overlooked by tourists, is the Sassetti chapel, covered in frescoes that are Ghirlandaio's masterpiece. The frescoes are famous, and like Raphael's Madonnas and Da Vinci's drawings, they are indelibly burned into our western minds, even if we have never seen them, for they seep into our common definitions of genius, civilization, beauty. Collective consciousness is what the socially minded scholar would call it. But Ghirlandaio, criticised by some as being a characterless painter, did well here. His images might not have the status of some of the more frequented gems of Florentine art, but they speak of the fervour and perfection of his time. He painted them in 1485, a few years before Savonarolla, the fiery Dominican who was eventually burned at the stake, took power in the city and a few years after the Pazzi conspiracy, in which Lorenzo de Medici narrowly escaped being murdered during mass in his own city's Duomo. These were dramatic times; art and politics were at a fever pitch.
But these frescoes, showing miracles from the life of Saint Francis, patron of the Sassetti family, don't even have a hint of drama. Even the blond haired boy, sitting up placidly after having fallen from a building and resuscitated by Francis, doesn't even have a bruise. I couldn't see this scene though, or for that matter many others, because the Sassetti chapel was occupied.
It was, in fact, occupied by a huge, custom built metal scaffold. The frescoes were being restored. The Italian State, which inevitably involves itself in these sorts of endeavours, had contracted a private company to clean and retouch the works. Art restoration is big business in Italy, and ever since the 1966 flooding of the Arno, Florence has been a hive of activity. The work, unbelievable, is drawing to a close, and the Sassetti chapel is among the last monuments to be tended to. As I approached the scaffolding, I noticed that it was being more than just cleaned, in fact. An art restorer, who in this country usually has the allure of a lab technician, was standing on the second level of the scaffold with a palette in his hand, touching up the Stigmatation of Saint Francis. He was using watercolours, plain pigment bound only with water, and a tiny sable hair paintbrush, and he was at work on Francis' feet, then the cloud of cherubs, then the distant hills. I was somewhat surprised at this rather dubious art restoration practice, especially on such a famous piece. It was, after all, an A1 monument, if we are to use such a glib rating system.
But there he was, the art restorer, carefully and lovingly filling in the tiny fragments of plaster that had flaked off the walls with the centuries. Nothing drastic, nothing that couldn't easily be removed by later restorers, but nonetheless, he was editing a Ghirlandaio, like a proof-reader would edit an essay. He made me jealous, and I had half the mind to ask him if I too could climb up on the scaffold and add a tiny little dot of paint, seamlessly blended into the already existing colour. I wanted to leave a mark. It was the same impulse that leads adolescents to scrawl lovers' names into the wall beside Juliet's balcony in Verona (like I did, I'll admit, at one time).
But I didn't ask, and instead I watched, fascinated, for some time, before finally moving on. My next stop was the Brancacci chapel, across the river in Oltrarno, a tiny chapel that is home to Masaccio's Tribute Money cycle; so iconic it is hardly worth mentioning. I don't agree particularly with its status in the history of art, but that's not something one can easily change. True, Michelangelo would come here when he was young and sketch the stern figure of Saint Peter, but that doesn't make it good art. As one of my professors would point out, Michelangelo made edits.
And then, east to Santa Croce, the monumental preaching barn of the Franciscans. The Florentines, too, charge admission to their churches. This must be a good idea, as even on a blustery Thursday afternoon in October there were at least a thousand visitors in the cavernous church, come to see the masterpieces by Giotto, Gaddi, Bruneleschi, or furthermore the tombs of Galileo, Michelangelo, or Rossini. This is, after all, a sort of Florentine Pantheon. There is even a grandiose monument to Dante,
l'optissimo poeta, even though the Florentines exiled him from their city and left him to die in Ravenna. Yet again, the lack of an irony manifests itself triumphantly.
Finally, before leaving Florence, I climbed up to the church of San Miniato al Monte, a glorious structure almost a thousand years old built entirely inlaid of green and white marble, so beautiful it resembles one of those Egyptian intarsia boxes they sell in Arab markets. From the terrace in front of the church, the famous view of Florence unfolds like an unbelievable painted panorama. As I looked out, I resigned myself to the fact that Florence would take a thousand visits to digest completely. Then, it started to rain.
A view of the Sassetti chapel before restorationThe Stigmatation of Saint Francis being "restored"Masaccio's Tribute Money, in the Brancacci ChapelThe façade of Sante CroceThe façade of San Miniato al MonteThe view of Florence from the terrace of San Miniato al Monte